ScrollBack to Top
Give the gift of an island!

Buy your 2019 gift certificates

Unique Island Sippers

Looking for the perfect island vacation libations?

We happily tasted every magically mixed beverage on Put-in-Bay to bring you our official Top 5 list. Bottoms up.


Island Rum & Island Vodka - Put-in-Bay Brewery & Distillery

If you visit Put-in-Bay’s very first Brewery & Distillery, you’ll be tempted to try their delicious craft beer selection. And you should! But for our money, their Rum and Vodka is the island party your mouth is waiting for.


Victory - Red Moon Saloon

Good news! We finally know what real victory tastes like: It’s Jameson + passion fruit puree + tres agave nectar + chianti. And you can only find it at the island’s favorite speakeasy, the Red Moon Saloon.


The Gas Dock - The Keys

Here’s “the key” to this frozen favorite: 151 Octane mixed with Rum Runner and topped with a Bacardi 151 Floater. And then stay at The Keys for another.


Filthy Little Oar Shot - Reel Bar

This is more than a shot—it’s a party tradition. Grab your friends, go to the Reel Bar, and knock a few of these Crown Royal concoctions back. And to answer your question: yes, it’s served on an oar.


Shark Shots - The Fishbowl

This is a must-try island favorite from The Fishbowl. It’s whiskey + Peach Schnapps + Cranberry Juice. Of course, it includes shooter-sized sharks to drink from. And of course, it’s delicious.

While you’re here, check out...