ScrollBack to Top
Give the gift of an island!

Buy your 2019 gift certificates

Dishes for Your Fish Wishes

As the Walleye Capital of the World (and a great spot for perch and bass), it goes without saying that we’ve enjoyed every catch we could. So we’re casting out our Top 5 favorite fish dishes on Put-in-Bay.

1

Walleye Sandwich - The Boat House

It’s a walleye-lovers wonderland. Lightly dipped in their signature beer batter and served on a grilled brioche roll with a side of fresh cut fries and house made tartar sauce. More like a WOW-eye sandwich.

2

Perch Tacos - The Goat Soup & Whiskey

The must-try fresh fish item at The Goat. Lightly breaded, perfectly fried, and wrapped in a soft tortilla with cabbage, tomato, green onion, cheese and their famous Pali Wali sauce. Only the freshest catch and ingredients. Get hooked.

3

Battle of Lake Erie Perch - The Keys

Who wins this Battle of Lake Erie? Well, with fresh Lake Erie Perch, a side of coleslaw and fries, and amazing lakefront views, the answer is you. Celebrate your victory with one of The Keys’ signature frozen drinks.

4

Reely Big Walleye Sandwich - Reel Bar

This isn’t just a clever name. This sandwich from The Reel Bar is HUGE. It’s fried to perfection and served with their famous homemade fries.

5

Perch & Pierogi basket - Mossbacks

This is a perfect one-two punch for your palate. Fresh and fried Lake Erie Yellow Perch with Pierogis, fried onions, and sour cream. Reel it in at Mossbacks.

While you’re here, check out...