ScrollBack to Top
Give the gift of an island!

Buy your 2019 gift certificates

Bites on the Bay

One of the most popular questions heard at Put-in-Bay is, “where is a good place to eat?”

Well, look no further. Because here's our Top 5 island flavors for you to feast on. Is your stomach growling? Good.

1

Hot Mess Breakfast at Pasquale’s

See if you can guess what’s missing from this dish: scrambled eggs, hash browns, bacon, sausage gravy, and cheddar and Monterey Jack cheese. The answer: nothing. If you’re a hot mess after a night of fun, this is the breakfast for you.

2

Hooley Cheese Dip from Hooligans

This special blend of warm cheeses from Hooligans is mixed with Andouille sausage and bacon. Yes, BACON! Even though it’s become a local after-drinking favorite, trust us…it’s just as mind-blowing stone sober.

3

Pizza at Frosty's Bar

You cannot go to Put-in-Bay without a slice of Frosty Pizza. Repeat that sentence. It’s a crisp-crusted, cheese-covered tradition that pairs great with a cold beer in a signature Frosty mug.

4

Wine-Basted Chicken at the Chicken Patio

This dish has been served to satisfying for more than 50 years—and was voted the best BBQ on Put-in-Bay. If you’re not sure where to find it, just follow the scent.

5

Lobster Bisque at The Boardwalk

The Boardwalk features the most iconic menu item on Put-in-Bay. It’s fresh. Made daily. And served in a baked bread bowl. It’s so good, you’ll almost forget to enjoy the view of the harbor while you’re eating it.

While you’re here, check out...